Assessing the Lars Eller-Brad Marchand Fight and the Bigger Issues at Hand

Geoff Burke-USA TODAY Sports

On Wednesday, the Washington Capitals opened their Stanley Cup title defense with a near-flawless dismantling of the Boston Bruins. Goaltender Braden Holtby was rarely tested, and the Caps high-flying offense picked up where it left off in June, scoring early and often. The only blemish on the 7-0 victory was a literal one; Lars Eller’s head was split open by a Brad Marchand right jab. 

If you were just looking at the box score, the bout was between two guys assessed fighting majors, with a two-minute instigator penalty added in, an occurrence that will happen hundreds of times this season. A deeper look uncovers larger problems for the National Hockey League.

First among these problems is the cause of Wednesday’s fight. Obviously, as any fan knows, there are many reasons fights occur. A coach tries to change the momentum. Retribution for a dirty hit. Two guys simply don’t like each other. This fight was none of those. It was the classic, “if you can’t beat them, beat them” fight.

Actually, it was worse than that. Typically a team’s enforcer, to the extent they any longer exist, will invite an opponent to dance, two willing participants dropping their gloves to battle. In this case, Marchand jumped Eller minutes after Eller’s first goal of the season put Washington up by a touchdown.

Marchand had his glove off to grab Eller and landed a couple of blows before Eller even knew there was a fight. Eller, suddenly in the first fight of his career, landed a few punches, before Marchand walloped the side of his head and landed a solid punch to Eller’s face.

Why did Marchand go after Eller? Did Lars curse Brad’s mother? Did he murder a litter of puppies at center ice? Nope. Marchand went after Eller because Eller dared to celebrate his goal in a manner that did not suit the Bruins.

Because he took an angle in front of their bench.  Really?

Eller’s goal was the exclamation point on a wonderful celebratory night in the District. The banner went up, the fans rocked, and the Caps power play rolled. Then Marchand and the Bruins got their feelings hurt so he went after Eller.

If we really need to break down Eller’s celebration, it included such awful and outlandish behavior as waving and skating past the Bruins bench on the way to his own.

The idea that it was beatdown-worthy is nonsense. If Marchand wanted to make someone physically answer for being down 7-0, he should have beaten up his own goalie and fellow penalty killers. Instead, Marchand chose to rough up Eller. All because Eller violated “The Code”. Unwritten malarkey that says a team or player must pay for excessive celebration. As if Brad “I like the way my opponents cheeks taste” Marchand is some caretaker of the game that enforces hockey’s etiquette and honor code. As if Brad Marchand is suddenly Emily Post on skates. Forgetting Marchand’s own plethora of past transgressions, what the heck are we even talking about with “The Code”?

Instead of licking their wounds, the Bruins tried to mete out some vigilante justice. This action is tiring. It is similar to the divide in baseball. If a hitter watches a homerun too long, or flips his bat too high in celebration, he is likely to get a fastball in his ear. The idea that a player can be seriously injured for celebrating too enthusiastically is as antiquated as it is stupid. At least Major League Baseball has started a campaign to change this mindset.

The NHL might want to consider the same. Too often, players feel they must deliver retribution for being checked cleanly. There was a time when, after getting decked, a player would get up, adjust his bucket, and wait for his opportunity to line up his checker for a hard hit later in the game. Now a scrum breaks out after almost every clean, hard hit.

Fighting used to serve a purpose; it was a deterrent, that in theory, prevented players from taking dangerous liberties. If you slashed Wayne Gretzky, you knew you had to answer to Marty McSorley. In fact, it is unlikely Marchand would have pulled his stunt with Tom Wilson in the Washington lineup. But the game may be evolving past the tough guy behavior that has long been identified with the sport.

A generational, seismic shift may be coming. If the NHL is as serious about eliminating brain injuries, as they claim, it should consider eliminating fighting altogether. Fighting is an electric, exciting part of the game, yet every incident like Wednesday night makes it seem silly and unnecessary.

Repeated head trauma from taking blows in fights can be as damaging as the type inflicted by hits like the ones for which Tom Wilson has been suspended. The possible link between fighting, Chronic Traumatic Encepalopathy, or CTE, and the death of enforcers such as Steve Montador, and Derek Boogaard is too important to easily dismiss.

Like the international game, the NHL could thrive without fighting. “The Code” is outdated. Is it time to bury the code and sanctioned on-ice fighting with it? If eliminating fighting meant ending the childish antics from Brad Marchand and knuckleheads like him, it might be worth it.

By Bryan Hailey

About Bryan Hailey

I have been a Washington Capitals fan for over thirty years. Some of my favorite memories are rocking the red with friends while cheering the Caps and rooting against their Patrick/Metropolitan Division rivals.
This entry was posted in News and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

28 Responses to Assessing the Lars Eller-Brad Marchand Fight and the Bigger Issues at Hand

  1. David says:

    Glad the guy who can’t stop licking other players feels a sense of moral superiority

  2. Paul says:

    Marchand is a dirtball to be sure. And weird. Maybe he should punch himself for licking other players. Eller just licked the team.

  3. Marchand is a piece of shit.

    If he was really upset about the Caps running up the score and people celebrating, why didn’t he go after Carlson (6-0), Kuzy (5-0), Dowd (4-0), Ovi (3-0), or anyone else? Maybe it was because he knows he woulda got the shit beat out of him by any of those guys so he went after the one guy who’s never been in a fight and is arguably the least confrontational guy on the squad.

    So yeah, Marchand is a piece of shit.

  4. Tom says:

    Your joking if you think Tom Wilson would have done anything to stop that fight. There would have been two fights instead, and they play a few more times so lets see what happens when he comes back. Secondly marchy called him out yes he didnt give Ellars a chance to say no, but he is a big guy and could have easily turtled. Dont try and tell me he has never locked up in practice before to learn to protect himself. Talk trash get smashed its hockey. Lastly of the six other goals prior who celebrated in front of the bruins bench…0. If it was against montreal and Weber kicked Ellars teeth in or tampa and Killhorn had his way with him, they would be applauded.

  5. Anonymous says:


  6. Joe Balls says:

    Bunch if people in NoVa that have never played hockey enough to know the unwritten rules. You don’t show-boat a meaningless goal toward the end of a blowout win. Act like you’ve been there before. There’s a line between a celly and show-boating. Cellying is fine but not show-boating. This isn’t football.

    • Russ Hook says:

      “Cellying” is NOT fine! (It’s a Mama’s Boy (Generation X) Thang that shows LACK of character. Show some respect for your opponent, and more IMPOTENTLY….yourself.

  7. Pingback: Don Cherry Rips Tom Wilson, Praises Brad Marchand On Hockey Night in Canada’s “Coaches Corner” Segment | NoVa Caps

  8. Pingback: Capitals’ Morning Skate News Roundup: Top-Line Stevie | NoVa Caps

  9. Pingback: Dallas at Washington Preview: Capitals Start Five-Game Homestand Against the Stars on Saturday Night | NoVa Caps

  10. Pingback: Capitals Morning Skate News: Injuries Pile Up In The Mile High City | NoVa Caps

  11. Pingback: Detroit at Washington Preview: Capitals Clash With Red Wings at Capital One Arena On Black Friday | NoVa Caps

  12. Pingback: Since Returning From Suspension, Tom Wilson is Turning Into Offensive Force For Capitals | NoVa Caps

  13. Pingback: Capitals Injury Updates On Michal Kempny, Alex Ovechkin, Evgeny Kuznetsov, T.J. Oshie, and Devante Smith-Pelly | NoVa Caps

  14. Pingback: Washington at Vegas Preview: Capitals Return To T-Mobile Arena For First Time Since Hoisting Stanley Cup, Visit Golden Knights In Battle Of League’s Hottest Teams | NoVa Caps

  15. Pingback: Washington at Carolina Preview: Capitals Take On Hurricanes in Raleigh | NoVa Caps

  16. Pingback: Capitals Hit Another Home Run With Under The Radar Signing Of Nic Dowd | NoVa Caps

  17. Pingback: Carolina at Washington Preview: Capitals Return From Holiday Break To Host Hurricanes on Thursday Night | NoVa Caps

  18. Pingback: Lars Eller, Capitals Seek Retribution on Bruins Forward Brad Marchand As Opening Night Rematch Nears | NoVa Caps

Leave a Reply